Eine wunderbare Studie, die ich über dieses Video gefunden habe:
Interpreting Malicious Responses to an Online Questionnaire about Transgender Undergraduate Engineering and Computer Science Student Experiences
Andrea Haverkamp , Finn Johnson , Michelle K. Bothwell , Qwo-Li Driskill , Devlin Montfort
Online research that solicits participation from marginalized communities or is conducted by scholars of marginalized identities may be targeted by individuals who intend to tamper with the study outcomes and/or harass the researchers. Our goal is to identify and interpret malicious responses recorded in a first-of-its-kind national questionnaire for transgender and gender nonconforming (TGNC) students in undergraduate engineering and computer science programs. Data categorized as malicious (50 of the 349 total responses) contained slurs, hate speech, or direct targeting of the research team. The data was coded inductively and discursively interpreted through social justice frameworks. The responses contained homophobic, transphobic, ableist, anti-Black, antisemitic, and anti-Indigenous content. Online memes associated with white nationalist and fascist movements were present throughout the data, alongside memes and content referencing gaming and “nerd” culture. Malicious responses can provide critical insight into the social conditions in STEM education. In application, we call for researchers to critically analyze, rather than discard, malicious data to shed light on these phenomena and generate empowering “counterspeech” to confront hate and reclaim agency. These findings show that social justice STEM education must include perspectives on online hate radicalization and center anti-colonial, intersectional solidarity organizing as its opposition.
Aus der Studie:
The demographics of the 50 malicious respondents are presented in Table 2. Throughout the rest of the paper, quotations from responses will be attributed to the respondent number from this table. Of note is that 12 respondents (24%) indicated their gender as being related to a helicopter or aircraft and that 15 of the 30 reporting disabilities (50%) referred to transgender identity or sexuality as a disability. Viewing this table gives an immediate snapshot of the tone and tenor of the malicious responses and the interplay between gender, sexuality, race, and ability.
Here are a few examples of demographics that show this interplay:
#2 – Aerosol [Gender], Afro/Klingon-Asiatic Galapogayation [Race], Being 2.86% White [Disability]
#17 – Airplane [Gender], Native American (Elizabeth Warren) [Race], Transgenderism [Disability]
#24 – Fucking white male [Gender] I’m a Swedish Muslim [Race], My country is run by communists [Disability]
#31 – pansexual attack helicopter [Gender], kangz [Race], intracranial lead deficiency [Disability]
Primary Themes
The following sections outline major patterns found in the responses. Select quotations are provided, along with their associated questions, as examples of how these patterns appeared in the data. Our methodology explicitly calls attention to the multiplicity of constructed identities that are subjugated across race, gender, citizenship status, religion, disability, and sexuality.Table 2. Demographics of the malicious respondents
#
Gender
Racial / Ethnic Identities
Disability (if indicated)
1
I identify as a gift card
I’m an ethnic gift card
I don’t have enough gift cards
2
Aerosol
Afro/Klingon-Asiatic Galapogayation
Being 2.86% white
3
Apache Attack Helicopter
American
–
4
Male
Puerto-Rican American
–
5
Apache Attack Helicopter
Erhnically diverse
–
6
Apconsugender
Black
I have hands where my feet are and feet where my hands are
7
Attack Helicopter
Ah-64 Apache
–
8
Bi Sexual
Black
–
9
big chungus
republican
autism
10
Gruy
Come on man, these questions are stupid. Everyone is a grab bag of genetics from all over the world
–
11
There are only two genders
There are only two genders
–
12
Transgender/ shemale
white
–
13
I’m an attack helicopter
my skin is blue, I think I might be a smurf
being an identitarian
14
?
Blasian15
Airplane
Black Hispanic Jew
Being trans
16
A human being.
STILL A HUMAN. this tells us even less information than gender. its the actual color of my skin. what else do you want to know? what i ate for breakfast. this question is unnecessary.
–
17
Airplane
Native American(Elizabeth Warren)
Transgenderism
18
Apache helicopter
Cracker
Gender disphoria
19
Cis gender lizard king
Eskimo
Thinking im not a man
20
DID YOU JUST FUCKING ASK FOR MY GENDER
DID YOU ASSUME MY RACE
Gender Disphoria
21
Electron GENDER
Colored Native Mix w/opressed ancestors.
Anxiety
22
F-16 Fighter Jet
US Military
That I’m a tranny.
23
Female
White24
Fucking white male
I’m a Swedish Muslim
My country is run by communists
25
helicopter
cherokee26
Hermaphrodite
African American
Transgenderism
27
homophobic biggot, yes we existwell i was born white but i spend a lot of time in the sun so i identify as a light skin black male
im mentally retarded
28
I identify as a boy when I’m getting fucked and a girl when I’m the one fucking. My dick goes inside out so it changes
I’m black on the inside but when I’m a boy I like getting my white ass fucked, you know what I’m sayin’ broh?
I’m sexually attracted to the thought of being eaten alive. I know this sounds like a joke, but I’m being serious. I’m a macrophile/vorephile and I jack off almost every night to the thought of a giantess women shoving me up her ass (to dip me in her sauce) and then throwing my body into her giant mouth. This isn’t a joke. I’m sexually suicidal and I jack off to death. The doctors say I have a disease but I find that really fucking hard to believe
29
Literal fluid
My skin color is not important.
Like all transgenders, my disability is the inability to come to terms with biological reality. Madness, essentially.
30
Bourne
–
31
pansexual attack helicopter
kangz
intracranial lead deficiency
32
Pedophile
Hispanic latina, native american black
pedohilia
33
Perfer not to say
Perfer not to say34
Quasi-Demi-poney; bankai-released state queercopter with a hint of faggotdrag lesbian and homosexual upside-down Frappuccino cake.
Everything that is native from the country of Africa.
Trans
35
Queer
KANGZ
Being transgender
36
Real n*
Real n*
Too ballin homie
37
There is only 2
White38
Agender
African-American
Depression/Anxiety
39
Trans hypocoagulated
I identify a Indian40
V22 osprey
Crip
nvm
41
Two-spirited demiqueer n*faggot attack helicopter kin
KANGZ
being transgender
42
Female
Black, Hispanic American, Hawaii Indian
My pride
43
transgendered lesbian
saiyan44
Non-binary inter-sectional African Mohammedian Feminist
African Jewish
Transgendered
45
Non-cookie-cutter cis-furry dragonkin. Don’t judge.
Homo sapiens, American46
N/A
Trans-black, trans-child, trans-asexual, pedosexual
Meth addiction
47
I’m just here for the gift card.
I’m just here for the gift card.48
Nonbinary queer
Hapa
Non-neurotypical cognitive ability (ADD, demisexual)
49
Trans male
Mixed
–
50
Transfemme rad butch
Black and native American
Illiterate